Topaz wrote:

you are very bold if you want to replace cleric with staff friar

when you dont want to grp with friar.. then its ok.. but let other their choice and dont flame any class setups . im sure you never had a friar in grp. so dont judge about other classes u dont know.
you wrote your opinion and i wrote mine.

I never flamed anyone, just told him my opinion based on experience. I was under the impression they want setup for rvr. And yes I had friar in group, because I have one level 50...

keep your arguments out of the thread please, the group setups are fine and decided.
If you want to post to join up feel free, otherwise please stop.

Topaz wrote:

you are very bold if you want to replace cleric with staff friar

when you dont want to grp with friar.. then its ok.. but let other their choice and dont flame any class setups . im sure you never had a friar in grp. so dont judge about other classes u dont know.
you wrote your opinion and i wrote mine.

Friars are ****** as group characters on Uthgard. You wrote your opinion, I wrote a fact.

Tank setup without Sorc? Will be fail I suppose - Sorc is needed in every kind of setup somehow ^^
(At least at the current state of Uthgard)

Sonnenschein wrote:Tank setup without Sorc? Will be fail I suppose - Sorc is needed in every kind of setup somehow ^^
(At least at the current state of Uthgard)

As I've said, this is primarily a leveling group. Why would we need a sorc? If for mezz, the last open slot can be a sorcerer or minstrel.

The response to this thread has frankly disappointed me.

Maybe it's because you are member of Black Adders? XD
Or maybe its because people don't get attracted by such *Big Plans* anymore since a lot of such actually failed?

In addition most of the forumtrolls don't play anymore or are quite loyal to their guilds.

Would be in, preferably random spot theurg, alternatively minstrel or bomb.

lippi wrote:Would be in, preferably random spot theurg, alternatively minstrel or bomb.

Awesome, we have a Merc, Theurg, Rejuv Cleric and one other (possibly) so far. so it looks like we'll be doing the melee group setup. Need more mercs and a paladin :]

yeah, would do the cleric-job in there

melee damage will be weak

u think he make only dmg on caster? rooofl sorry ... you write big crap....

and without determination unreliable

friars can spec Det.......
sorry pls write better arguments..

so far we have:

Tobold (undecided...)
Lippi (Theurg)
Higos (Cleric)
Rhyniel (Merc)
Jonah (Cleric)

So we just need a paladin, and 2 more Mercs. Last spot will probably go to a Sorc so we can RvR in BGs

You should post that in ur first posting, so ppl can see there is sth going quickly without reading all this balance trash talk.

pweet wrote:You should post that in ur first posting, so ppl can see there is sth going quickly without reading all this balance trash talk.

good idea, thanks.

I'll join as a Merc.

I have a guildy who has a low paladin as well

Hoppip wrote:I'll join as a Merc.

I have a guildy who has a low paladin as well

Excellent, what lvl paladin and whats his name?

Before we start we will all have to create the characters, post names on this thread and get the chars to lvl5. Once we're all lvl5 we will begin group xp sessions